Tax loss carry-forward

Top  Previous  Next

Q:  I don't think our tax loss carry-forward is correct.

 

A:  Thanks for your question about the tax loss carry-forward.  I regret that the calculations do not show on your reports because it would be easier to see the effects.

Your parent company's tax bill is based on consolidated income, rather than only the income in the home area.  Taxes paid by subsidiaries constitute a credit to the parent company tax bill.  Current period income is reduced by a tax loss carry-forward, if any, from the previous quarter.

The calculation is easy to see when there is a consolidated net loss, as you had in Year 3, Quarter 1.

Consolidated Net Loss Before Tax

$-101

Less Income Tax paid by subsidiaries

 
 - 60

Net Loss after tax

$-161

Note that this is not the same as the loss in Area 1 ($-206), attributed to the parent company.  The subsidiaries paid $60 tax on $154 income (60/.39).  This income, already taxed to the subsidiary, reduces the consolidated loss.  Adding it back establishes the tax loss carry-forward for the parent:

Consolidated Net Loss Before Tax

$-101

Taxes paid by subsidiaries ($60)
Less Subsidiary Income already taxed

 
 
$-154

Parent tax-loss carry-forward

$-255

Then, in Year 3, Quarter 2,

Consolidated Net Loss Before Tax

 $188

Less tax loss carry-forward

-255

Consolidated Taxable Income

$ -67

Taxes paid by subsidiaries ($85)
Less subsidiary income

 
-218

Parent tax-loss carry-forward

$-285

Note that there is a tax loss carry-forward, even though there was a profit of $207 in Area 1, due to the loss in Sereno.

Then, in Year 3, Quarter 3:

Consolidated Net Loss Before Tax

 $-138

Less tax loss carry-forward

-285

Consolidated Taxable Income

$ -423

Taxes paid by subsidiaries ($-101)
Less subsidiary income

 
-259

Parent tax-loss carry-forward

$-682

In Year 3, Quarter 4 there was a consolidated profit

Consolidated Net Loss Before Tax

 $437

Less tax loss carry-forward

-682

Consolidated Taxable Income

$ -245

Taxes paid by subsidiaries ($-226)
Less subsidiary income

 
-579

Parent tax-loss carry-forward

$-824

During Year 4, your firm had a consolidated net profit each quarter, including untaxed profits in Sereno (not taxed because of a peso tax loss carry-forward).  It may be instructive for you to "do the sums" for the first three quarters of Year 4.  At the end of Quarter 3, the tax loss carry-forward was $169 thousand.

For Year 4, Quarter 4:

Consolidated Net Loss Before Tax

$1456

Less tax loss carry-forward

-169

Consolidated Taxable Income

$1287

Tax at 39%

502

Taxes paid by subsidiaries

-370

Net tax bill for parent company

$132